Neurips desk reject If my paper was desk-rejected from a conference or journal and I received no reviewer feedback, does it still need to be declared as a resubmission? Answer: Yes, it should still be declared and you should still describe any changes that have been made to the current version. Apparently, at least for the ACs, the desk reject nominations have been removed from their CMT system. within each tier. 6% acceptance rate includes papers that were desk rejected for formatting violations or withdrawn before they received reviews. If the results are “known results” (I’m pretty confident they aren’t), perhaps the area chair could have made the effort to leave a note telling what they are? 1/n — Sinead Williamson (@sineadwilliamso) July 13, 2020 根据NeurIPS 2020的实验显示，如果给予了完整审稿的机会，大约有6%被直接拒稿（desk reject）的论文可能会被录用。考虑到这个结果以及领域主席需要花费额外的时间决定直接拒稿的论文，今年我们决定不引入直接拒稿机制。然而，对于不遵守基本要求（例如论文 Mar 10, 2025 · 1) NeurIPS 2024 Conference Schedule. - The submission was incomplete - The submission was too long (over 8 pages of content) - The submission had significant margin violations - The submission did not use the NeurIPS 2020 Latex style file - The submission was not anonymous - The submission has incorrect page size 很捉急，因为Abstract太短，NeurIPS 2019的投稿直接被Desk Reject了，有没有哪位大神有多余的Paper ID可… Apr 10, 2021 · 根据 NeurIPS 2020 试验的结果，如果经过完整的审稿流程，大约有 6% 的直接拒稿（desk rejection）论文可能会被接收。因此，NeurIPS 2021 今年决定取消 desk Count: #Total = #Accept + #Reject + #Withdraw + #Desk Reject - #Post Decision Withdraw. May 22, 2021 · 因此，NeurIPS 2021 今年决定取消 desk rejection。但如果论文违反页数限制或其他提交要求，仍可能会被拒稿，无需经过审核。为了最大程度地减少审稿过程中的偏见和误解，NeurIPS 2021 组委会将在提交初审和作者反馈后允许作者与审稿人进行「滚动讨论」。 May 27, 2020 · In order to cope with the growing number of submissions, this year we will adopt an “early desk-reject” process involving only Area Chairs and Senior Area Chairs. AAAI2025投稿教程，被desk reject是一种什么样的体验，原因是何？以后如何避免？, 视频播放量 3556、弹幕量 2、点赞数 49、投硬币枚数 8、收藏人数 41、转发人数 22, 视频作者 Zhao_Song, 作者简介，相关视频：AAAI2025投稿教程，或许只有在deadline前没有来得及把模版改完，错过了投稿，才会深刻的学会如何 . 2) NeurIPS 2024 Workshops. AAAI转投的，看AAAI的评价，如果里面提到的缺点没改掉，那就可以拒。 2. The Datasets and Benchmarks track serves as a venue for high-quality publications, talks, and posters on highly valuable machine learning datasets and benchmarks, as well as a forum for discussions on how to improve dataset development. However, authors of rejected submissions will have two weeks after the notification deadline to opt in to make their de-anonymized papers public and open for commenting in OpenReview. Editors will usually choose to desk reject manuscripts because (1) they have obvious methodological flaws, (2) they 1 3 CVPR 2025的可能desk reject如果openreview信息不全, 视频播放量 2153、弹幕量 1、点赞数 26、投硬币枚数 7、收藏人数 7、转发人数 8, 视频作者 simapofang, 作者简介，相关视频：计算机启蒙之水浒传[第1期]，2025年秋，博士申请的面试大概是什么样子的？ PCs may want to programmatically desk-reject submissions that are missing PDF files once the submission deadline has passed. Jul 24, 2020 · 最近，有关收到大会领域主席 Desk reject 的消息时常出现在社交网络上。在一些人收到的邮件中，NeurIPS 表示：「由于 NeurIPS 近年来论文提交数量大幅增长，会方难以找到足够数量的评审者。我们今年收到了史无前例的 9467 篇论文提交。 The reviewing process is double blind at the level of ACs; each AC will work with a senior area chair (SAC), who is responsible for cross checking desk reject recommendations, identifying conflicts of interest (and other unusual activity, such as suspicious bidding patterns) and re-assigning submissions to ACs or reviewers accordingly. Area Chairs will be responsible for identifying papers that are very likely to be rejected, and Senior Area Chairs will cross check the selections. The information entered in the profile is critical for ensuring that conflicts of interest and reviewer matching are handled properly. NeurIPS 2024 workshops will take place on Dec. Because of the rapid growth of NeurIPS, we request that all authors help with reviewing papers, if asked to do so. Avg. This year NeuRIPS has over 10000 submissions (double the size of ICML 2020), so even after desk-rejection phase, which assuming 85% of this amount will receive fu (EiC) or a senior/deputy editor will read each paper and decide whether to reject it or for-ward to a handling editor for consideration for publication. . Some of this inconsistency was due to “false positives”—papers that did not actually have issues of concern to Ethics Reviewers, but that were I completely agree. cc 6 days ago · Submissions without the authors' updated OpenReview profiles will be desk rejected. Apr 15, 2022 · 这种没有经过外审就被拒的情况一般称为 Desk rejection 或 Desk reject，可以理解为手稿刚摆上主编的桌子，就被直接退回了。有编辑表示，以下3个问题至少有一个为否定回答就会被 Desk rejection（具体因期刊而异，仅供参考哦）：感觉没有违反任何格式要求. Make sure to replace <venue_id> with the venue ID of your conference. min/max/mean/std: These calculations are based on the R. Thank you for agreeing to serve as a reviewer for NeurIPS 2024! ACs make initial accept/reject decisions with SACs: Fri, Aug 30 - Mon, Sep 9. 大数据文摘出品NeurIPS2020评审系统发生了重大改变。昨天，NeurIPS团队在medium专栏发布公告，宣布了2020会议投稿和评审的几项重要变化。增加 pre-reject 阶段；所有论文作者需要完成被分配的论文评审任务；有修… 提前拒稿应该是参考了IJCAI2020的做法。我参与了IJCAI2020的summary reject, 实操过程中，reject的有两类： 1. 审稿已经开始，有审稿人反应收到了没有实验部分的paper，desk reject质量堪忧。已经出了，推特上已经有人开始抱怨了，甚至看到几个AC也在抱怨其他AC给desk reject却不好好写理由。 See full list on neurips. We received 204 total submissions — a significant increase from last year. Apr 9, 2021 · By default, rejected submissions will not be made public. Without desk-rejection we will essentially overload reviewers and the risk of having low-quality reviews is very high. The details are posted on the conference website. Jul 18, 2020 · 在两次推迟 Deadline 之后，全球人工智能顶会 NeurIPS 2020 终于到了论文评审阶段。最近，有关收到大会领域主席 Desk reject 的消息时常出现在社交网络上。在一些人收到的邮件中，NeurIPS 表示：「由于 NeurIPS 近年来论文提交数量大幅增长，会方难以找到足够数量的评审者。我们今年收到了史无前例的 9467 篇论文提交。因此，我们今年使用了摘要拒稿程序：每篇论文都会经过两名不同有经验的研究者评估（领域主席 AC 和高级领域主席 SAC），决定论文是否需要接受进一步的评审。根据 NeurIPS 官方统计，今年大会的论文提交数量比上一年增长了 38%，再次刷新了 NeurIPS 史上的提交数量记录。最近，有关收到大会领域主席 Desk reject 的消息时常出现在社交网络上。在一些人收到的邮件中，NeurIPS 表示：「由于 NeurIPS 近年来论文提交数量大幅增长，会方难以找到足够数量的评审者。我们今年收到了史无前例的 9467 篇论文提交。 Apr 22, 2024 · Submissions without updated OpenReview profiles will be desk rejected. From this great batch of submissions, we have accepted 56 workshops. 文章十分粗糙的，明显就是赶制的，比如排版混乱、图片遮住了文字这种。 Jun 13, 2022 · Thank you for agreeing to serve as a reviewer for NeurIPS 2022! ACs make initial accept/reject recommendations with SACs: Thursday, Aug 26 – Thursday, September 因此，NeurIPS 2021 今年决定取消 desk rejection。但如果论文违反页数限制或其他提交要求，仍可能会被拒稿，无需经过审核。为了最大程度地减少审稿过程中的偏见和误解，NeurIPS 2021 组委会将在提交初审和作者反馈后允许作者与审稿人进行「滚动讨论」。 Dec 3, 2021 · And these differences are more stark than they appear since the 25. Reject (in Table) represents submissions that opted in for Public Release. Seems like we will eventually get desk rejects; they simply haven't been announced yet. Jul 14, 2020 · The conference NeurIPS instituted a new reviewing policy this year: “In order to cope with the growing number of submissions, this year we will adopt an “early desk-reject” process involving Jul 16, 2020 · Oh, great. Neurips desk reject. Rates: Status Rate = #Status Occurrence / #Total. NeurIPS 2024 Datasets and Benchmarks Track If you'd like to become a reviewer for the track, or recommend someone, please use this form. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 14 & 15. ioiq zax uffjaar okm vdgu hfym yhou vag bnjj mabbv dbg owfe rchfv ddqfg mbkmg

Neurips desk reject. 2) NeurIPS 2024 Workshops.